What Happened to Roman Catholic Culture?

Traditional vs. Novus Ordo

The pre-Vatican II Church culture, on the parish level at least, was a vibrant, robust culture that embraced its uniqueness and derived much of Her strength from the global communities who pledged the care of their souls to the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church. It was a Church that centered itself on the priesthood, the Sacraments, the prayers of the Saints and of course, its devotion to Mary. It was a bulwark against the world, the flesh and the devil and strengthened its members with the faith, hope and charity which stitched the whole of the Church together. Its centrality to the lives of the Catholic families around the world attested to the belief that this was surely the Church that Christ had founded and thereby drew close to the never-changing constancy of its Truths which were taught or instilled amongst all of its members: Truths which had stood the test of time and would be held in perpetuity.
     Like all cultures that are united in will and purpose, the Catholic Church embraced its own language, music, rites, customs and celebrations which it shared with the world; spreading its influence far and wide throughout the wider cultures of many countries and civilizations. It was a source of constancy, in a world of perpetual change, a certainty in the midst of ambiguity and doubt. It was at once, both ancient and new as it transformed and invigorated the children of the Church with the ever-new spiritual direction of Her saints and martyrs, punctuated with their numerous miracles and prophecies, and igniting the love and devotion of every Catholic. All of this filled Her ranks with those who dreamt of attaining holiness and filled them with the common desire to emulate the lives of these most extraordinary men and women. It was a safe haven from the troubles of this world and a comfort to all the broken lives and suffering souls. One might even say that it might be likened to a salvific balm or salve which contained a seemingly inexhaustible supply of paternal healing strength and maternal love. And for Her children of faith, She was a small piece of heaven living amidst the torments and temptations of a fallen world.
     It was a culture that embraced a True Egalitarianism, not the egalitarianism of this world that tries to eliminate differences and uniqueness; for it made everyone equal in the thing that counts most . . . our quest for eternal happiness and holiness . . . to be counted amongst the saints of Christ’s own Church. It was a Church that was distinct among Christians, known for the penitential signs of Ash Wednesday, meatless Fridays, and days of fasting and abstinence. We had duties to perform: days of Holy Obligation, Confessions, penance for sins. And we celebrated quite openly our joy of the saints and especially our love of Mary, with festivals and feast days throughout the year. We were united by a deep love and respect for the men of God that were given us; the priests, bishops and of course, the Pope. This culture defined us more than any other characteristics that we might bare; race, language, wealth or social status.
      These past 50 years has seen a loss of much that united us as a Catholic culture. We have lost or suppressed our common language, music, rites, customs and celebrations. In short, we have become more like everyone else. Our external and internal culture has been nearly extinguished and our once vibrant and robust uniqueness has been rendered rather anemic as a distinct Catholic culture. We have largely lost our confidence, our respect and our joy of being a member of this ancient faith. We have lost our identity. It might well be said that we no longer know who we are, how we should act, how we should worship or what we must believe. It is quite often a joyless faith and only temporally and humanly happy in the sense that the world envisions happiness: smiles, pats on the back, clapping for one another, giving recognition to each other and living out our own subjective faith apart, in a divine sense, from one another. The unity of the Catholic culture no longer exists. Factions have multiplied and individualism is celebrated and encouraged whilst the old is denigrated and the new is viewed as a blossoming of the faith out into the world. The embroidered richness of the ancient Church is now replaced with polyester and felt, classical art replaced with smiley faces. A rich tradition and culture, uniquely Catholic, is now superseded by the same vulgar culture that the world supplies and embraces. The marble altars have been stripped and replaced with wooden tables as we now celebrate a common meal instead of the Sacrifice of all sacrifices. It is all about community, though the community of our common culture and our heritage has been destroyed. We have been robbed and given a stone though we asked for bread; a snake though we asked for fish.
     Where once we went unto the Altar of God Who gave joy to our youth we now go unto a table of men where the remnant faithful lament the loss of our Catholic identity and in some instances the faith itself. They decry a watered down, Protestantized hybrid Church that seems to have lost its memory as well as its zeal to save souls: having become light on teaching and training in the things of God and heavy on eliminating social injustice rather than the development of the virtues and righteousness. For it has become a Church long on excuses for sinful living and short on providing the means for forming souls in the pursuit of holiness. Psychology, social and political science has made theology and spiritual formation nearly obsolete.
      Such is the reality that dawns on me today: that it was much easier to love God and His Church when we were consoled by a culture that prepared us for our natural end: God Himself. But when the consolations end, how much harder it is to love God and His Church when both have seemingly withdrawn their blessings. To love God for Who He is and not simply for what blessings He brings us is a maturation of love; the kind of love that God is desirous to receive from His Bride . . . a sacrificial love. Is this perhaps the point in the Passion of Christ’s Church where She cries out, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” The current crisis of faith seems to indicate that such a thought is not overly far-fetched.
      If this is the time of purgation and darkness, one might expect a dark night of the Soul for the Catholic Church. Can we continue in this darkness until we once again find the Living Flame of Love lighting our way into the next world? I know the Church will succeed and I pray that I too might remain faithful in this spiritual pilgrimage even in the face of spiritual dryness. By faith we must accept, though unknown to us, that everything, which is unfolding presently, was eternally known as part of the Divine plan of Almighty God. May He forever remain Lord over our hearts and minds and bring us to Everlasting Life. We must continually remind ourselves that our prayer needs to be; not my will but may Thy Holy Will be done.

4 thoughts on “What Happened to Roman Catholic Culture?

  1. It is surprising that Catholic culture should hold so little sway when post-modernism, i.e. the prevailing culture of selfish individualism and agnosticism, has nothing to offer save the pursuit of pleasure and the esteem of one’s peers. On one level, the parents and perhaps grandparents of the current generation have some blame for not passing on a vital faith to their children. On another level, modern-day Catholic literature, the main vehicle for passing down culture, seems far removed from the main stream. The only popular, contemporary Catholic novel I can recall is Sword and Serpent by Taylor Marshall. Other than that, Catholics seem to mostly draw their reading material from earlier times. Without vibrant Catholic letters (and perhaps television) inflaming the moral imagination of Catholics, it is easy to see how many Catholics would find the Church dull and uninspiring, which is very sad.

    Liked by 1 person

    • It is sad, indeed. I only wish most Catholics were so well formed that they even read something Catholic at all. I would that they read the books prior to the Council for a better explanation of what we still believe. But, alas, not many even remember those days of old and our own culture would seem strange to them as they are more Protestant in their thinking than most Protestants of the early 20th century.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Augustine talks about this extensively in Confessions and the City of God. For a long time I’ve attempted to juggle the modern world and my faith, I was concerned with being completely genuine in my faith and being labeled as an outdated bigot. I believe Catholics, and for that matter, Christians must reject the notion of acceptance in the modern world and the acceptance of those who value only the City of Man.

        It’s not that folks are “protestant” in their thinking, sometimes I wish Catholics were more like Missouri Synod Lutherans with their devotion to their mass; however, the inherent issue I believe is what my Orthodox friend explains is the acid of Classical Liberalism that eats away every single institution. It attacks old world conservatism, destroys the traditional family, and wishes to eliminate traditional institutions and communities.

        I’ve studied extensively early American history in my course work. Around 1774, Colonists were given the power from the First Continental Congress to create committees that acted like agencies of local government created to resist the coercive acts. The committees acted like inquisitions and in all honestly do not create the romantic image of revolution that most Americans are brought up to believe. The committees were not overly violent, of course, there would be the occasional tar and feathering but for the most part what they relied on was public humiliation. Now the reason, I explain this is because I certainly believe that this method employed today with social media. Catholic culture suffers out of the fact that no one wants to be ostracized by the social media. Classical Liberalism armed with the technological area, uses the weapon in effect to silence their enemies.

        It’s hard to navigate, because it’s certainly hard to be an American without being a Classical Liberal. Just some thoughts.


        • They do indeed. Our society has become rotten from the inside and has no looks of turning around soon. And we, as Catholics, have not the stomach that we did when we began our journey; the faith of the martyrs and saints. Few are willing to preach the truth in season and out of season it seems. All we have done is delayed the coming persecution and have lost the respect of those Christians who are willing to give their all to this battle between God and the forces of evil. Maybe we will get a little backbone after we suffer a bit more.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s